As I was reading about Elena Kats-Chernin, I discovered some musical influences of hers, and thought it would be beneficial for students to engage in some study of their work. I incorporated a work from Tchaikovsky and Brahms for a melodic dictation, performance activity and comparative analysis in order to give a broader scope of the conception of ‘Eliza’s Aria’ and the musical background of Elena Kats-Chernin herself.
Audio excerpt for Tchaikovsky – Theme from Swan Lake
Audio excerpt for Brahms – Hungarian Dance No.5
Manuscript excerpt for Swan Lake and Hungarian Dance No.5
I selected these pieces as they shared some similarities with ‘Eliza Aria’ and had parts that were suitable for melodic dictation at this stage of learning. I downloaded the YouTube files and edited them in Soundtrap only selecting a suitable portion of the piece (in relation to difficulty). The Manuscript excerpt will be a 2-sided sheet where it is differentiated for those who can do the melodic dictation with very little assistance and those who need more assistance. I tried to be as strategic as possible when it came to revealing notes; not revealing step-wise scale movement or leaps that could be identified within reason.
I found a quote on Chernin’s musical influences and thought it would be useful for a classroom discussion covering topics like the nationalities of the composers, the context of their compositions and identifying similarities/differences between their music and Chernin’s music.
I made this PowerPoint Slide on Elena Kats-Chernin for the class discussion
(Article on Elena Kats-Chernin which features the quote on the slide)
I created a Guided Comparative Analysis Sheet to assist students in the comparative analysis but also to use it as tool to help them distinguish the concepts of music and how to match them with what they are hearing.